In a comment to another post, Andrey sent in a link to this blog post, titled “Never judge a programmer by their commit history”. Â It’s very similar to something that I wanted to write for quite some time now.
It’s been a very long time since I judged any programmer based on their commit history and I believe if you think you can judge a programmer’s ability by reading his/her code YOU ARE WRONG.
As technical folk, we are often fast to judge an implementation purely on its technical merits, forgetting, that there are other factors often at play. Â Mehdi Khalili, the author of the post, goes over just some of them, including:
- Abiding by bad coding standards
- Bad leader and project manager
- Junior devs
- Business reality
- Brain fart
- Personal issues
- Synergy or lack thereof
- Physical issues (which is similar to the Personal issues above)
- Imposters! (which is funny and, something I didn’t think about)
I’ve seen (and done) almost all of these. Â Business reality and junior devs are the two I’ve come across the most.